Lab Exit Ticket 11/6 – zaneroggenbuck

Topic:

I am most likely going to contrast the way Americans talk about access to gender-affirming care vs. firearms, as the rhetoric is similar but one is much more restricted than the other while being arguably much less impactful to the public.

Message:

My thinking is that you have to be older, and go through a much longer and more difficult approval process, to get proper gender-affirming care than you do to get a gun in the U.S, even though the concerns posed to support the former (that it “risks” permanent bodily changes, that you need to be very mentally stable and responsible, that you could endanger other people or make them feel unsafe) are arguably much truer of the latter.

Hook:

Something like “18, mentally unstable, but never committed a felony? In five days, you can put a bullet in anyone you want. 19 and gender dysphoric? Hormones are quite risky, let’s check back in a few months.”

Connections:

People Care: Health, dignity, and autonomy. Why are rights to have the body you choose less free than rights to defend that body even at grave cost to others? And why do we judge people in public more for one than for the other?

Fair Share: Access, power. Does being “male / female-bodied” in the opposite gender’s context really confer that much power or “privilege”? Does openly carrying a lethal-force weapon as a civilian in public not do so?

 

Leave a Reply

Got a question? Need Help?
Have a suggestion?

Get in touch with Prof Joline Blais or TA Cecilia Andrade via