9/15
- One of the situations in which I feel most in control of my attention is when I’m out walking, often when I’m further away from “home”. If I have an objective to get to a place or get back home, I am able to focus on that objective much better than I am on most other tasks; if I do not, I often find myself able to let my thoughts drift to a place where I am relaxed or comfortably pensive.
- This may be an odd one, but as someone who has difficulty communicating and worries about it a lot, messaging apps and email can often be something that both helps me communicate effectively, and also distracts me and allows me to procrastinate performing necessary communication. When I was in high school and was receiving a huge variety of emails, the latter in particular often ended up being a place where I spent as much time reading utterly irrelevant information, either to satisfy the urge to keep up or directly to put off sending a difficult message, as I did actually sending messages or finding important info.
- One app/platform feature that comes to mind for me is Reddit’s post update features, which are on by default to various degrees and send in-app notifications whenever someone comments on your post or if said post reaches a certain threshold of attention. Especially considering the latter kind of notification which feels very mechanical, these features feel to me like they encourage micromanagement and constant rumination on what one has posted. I think a good starting point for a redesign might be turning this feature off by default (there is a prompt to get the highest level of notifications every time you post, which I think should be removed entirely), and doing away with the automatic attention threshold type of notifications, which I believe hold little human value.
9/17
3. Coming back to the example of Reddit post notifications I used last time:
- This design prioritizes a user’s engagement with their own posts and the reception thereof over engagement with others’ posts or indeed, other content outside of the platform. This encourages a style of online presence that is once both highly self-centered, and also utterly dependent on others’ actions and perception of oneself, especially for those who are highly motivated by their online appearance.
- I’d say the main encoded value of this feature is connection, but a very particular kind of connection, closer to communications than conversation, that is not necessarily very communal or humane in nature.
- I think the main beneficiary of the feature is the platform, not the user, as this is another way to keep the user engaged with the platform, even if it doesn’t involve as much content or advertising consumption as the other, more prolific techniques of engagement. In my opinion, most users who experience the feature don’t meaningfully benefit from it.
3b. Thinking bigger, one practice I think we should examine is the short release cycles / frequent rotation of smartphone models. This enriches manufacturers and providers (notably carriers), with comparably less benefit to consumers, who are expected to upsell themselves for upgrades that can be excessive, and are along the way made to accept new technology they may actively dislike (such as more advanced tracking features on new hardware), and encouraged to treat this hardware as more disposable and temporary than they otherwise would. All the while, this format carries a significantly higher environmental cost compared to the longer release cycles of other kinds of computers, and, to some extent, sabotages the ability of the overall market to support such longer release cycles, imprisoning even modestly old phones in the budget segment of the market. I think we should consider drastically slowing down phone release cycles to a pace closer to that of desktop computers or laptops, releasing new hardware every few years instead of every year or two, and providing new software upgrades and support for at least the better part of a decade. This would greatly reduce the environmental cost and cost to consumers, while likely improving the health of the market.